Recent ODRA Cases
Results: - 3 Records found
| FAA Order | ODRA-08-455 | |||
| Matter | Bid Protests of Diversified Management Solutions, Inc. and Alaska Weather Operations, Inc. Pursuant to Solicitation No. DTFAWA-07-R-00006 | |||
| Docket | 08-ODRA-00430 and 08-ODRA-00431 (Consolidated) | |||
| Date Served | 05/23/2008 | |||
| Decision | Protests sustained. The protests of Diversified Management Solutions, Inc. and Alaska Weather Operations Services, Inc. cumulatively challenged a total of three contract awards made pursuant to Solicitation No. DTFAWA-07-R-00006 for the performance of non-automated contractor weather operation services. Among other things, the protests challenged the FAAs evaluation of proposals and determinations of eligibility for award. During the proceedings, the Program Office filed a motion to dismiss the Alaska Weather protest which was denied and granted in part. Alaska Weathers challenges to the terms of the Solicitation were summarily dismissed as untimely, but the remaining challenges against the technical and price evaluations of both the Alaska Weather and the awardees proposals were found to present timely and justiciable issues that required adjudication in accordance with the ODRAs Procedural Regulations. (Decision on Motion to Dismiss). On the merits, the ODRA found that the proposals of the awardees and the protesters received disparate treatment and that the evaluation plan used in the evaluation was not consistent with the terms of the solicitation. The ODRA recommended that both protests be sustained and that the Program Office be directed to reopen the competition for the groups protested. (Findings and Recommendations and Order). | |||
| FAA Order | 08-TSA-031[Pending] | |||
| Matter | Bid Protest of Ribeiro Construction Company, Inc. Pursuant to Solicitation No. HSTS04-08-R-CT8021 | |||
| Docket | 08-TSA-031 | |||
| Date Served | 04/30/2008 | |||
| Decision | Suspension request denied. Protester challenged the award of a contract by TSA for design and construction of a baggage handling test facility. Protester requested a suspension of contract activities during the pendency of the Protest. The ODRA concluded that although the Protester had alleged a substantial case, that it had not demonstrated that irreparable injury would occur in the absence of a suspension. The ODRA further concluded that the comparative injuries and the public interest in maximizing the security of the air transportation system without delay outweighed possible economic injury to the Protester. (Decision on Request for Suspension). | |||
| FAA Order | ODRA-08-441 | |||
| Matter | Bid Protest of CNI Aviation, LLC Pursuant to Solicitation No. DTFAAC-07-R-02224 | |||
| Docket | 07-ODRA-00428 | |||
| Date Served | 02/07/2008 | |||
| Decision | Protest dismissed. CNI Aviation, LLC (CNI) filed a bid protest with the ODRA on December 17, 2007. The CNI Protest challenged the Findings and Recommendations and Final Order issued on November 21, 2007, in the bid protest of HyperNet Solutions, Incorporated, ODRA Case No. 07-ODRA-00416. The ODRA dismissed the CNI Protest for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted and for lack of timeliness. CNI sought to challenge the implementation of a remedy that had been ordered in the earlier bid protest of HyperNet Solutions, Inc. No. 07-ODRA-00416. In the earlier bid protest, the Administrators Delegee, acting on the recommendation of the ODRA, had directed that the HyperNet Protest be sustained and that the challenged contract be awarded to HyperNet. The ODRA concluded that there was no legal basis for CNI to challenge in a new protest a remedy that had been ordered in the HyperNet Protest. The ODRA further concluded that the CNI Protest had not been timely filed. (Findings and Recommendation and Order). | |||
| << Top >> < New Search > | ||||
